Students Lose Diplomas Over Cheers

I think this is ridiculous. Sometimes people will go the extra mile to ruin a special moment. When I graduated our principal told us that if we tossed our hats in the air at the end of the ceremonies we would not be given our diploma. I thought that was a little exteme too.
 
This is my opinion,but they were warned beforehand that the students relatives had to behave or they knew the consequences.I can kind of see the point of school administrators too.One is a safety factor.It is such a shame that school functions can go out of control to the point where violence happens.There are some parents who have complained because they couldn't hear the name of their child walking across the stage,but being drowned out by the excitement from relatives and friends.I would be very upset too.I went to my daughter's high school graduation and it was so loud that you couldn't hear anything because of the rowdy graduates family and friends.
 
Last edited:
When I graduated our principal told us that if we tossed our hats in the air at the end of the ceremonies we would not be given our diploma. I thought that was a little exteme too.

We were told the same thing.
To have the students and their families sign a contract though....a bit extreme, but I can see why it might be neccesary.
 
I can see the neccesity of saying "Please hold your applause" because the next student name may not be heard but to take away a diploma and the signed contract is a bit extreme. But then again - isnt society in all aspects becoming extreme?

Our val prompted us to pull out our sunglasses during a certian point in his speech - principal caught wind and told us not to do it and if we did he would never write a recommendation for any of us. His daughter was class pres and said do it anyway - we did - he was mad - he got over it I guess.....
 
The graduation last week at the high school where I teach was horrible. I collected 4 beachballs during the ceremony, and several other teachers collected more. I collected several cans of silly string, as did other teachers. Not 10 minutes into the ceremony the graduates were already bouncing beachballs and spraying each other with silly string, including during the senior chorus members' very last performance together. This continued throughout the ceremony. They were spraying each other with silly string before some of them had walked across the stage and had their picture made-- not only did they ruin their own graduation, but they ruined the pictures of it as well. When parents saw us taking the beachballs and silly string, they booed us and yelled that the kids were just having fun. It was terrible. I was looking forward to seeing several outstanding students graduate that I've gotten to know this year but I wasn't able to hear their names called or see them walk across the stage because I was so busy trying to keep the rowdy students quiet. It was just horrible.

People did not dress appropriately either. Many parents showed up wearing jeans and tie-dyed t-shirts. I even saw a baby in a stroller wearing only a diaper. Graduation is a formal event-- at the very least your entire family should come fully clothed! The graduates also didn't dress appropriately-- most of the guys wore shorts and icky old birkenstocks so you could see their hairy legs and ugly feet as they walked across the stage. It was not attractive.

This was the first time I've attended graduation so I was pretty shocked. And mad. I spend all day every day making sure every student in my class has the opportunity to walk across that stage and they don't even care enough to give their own accomplishment the respect it deserves, and neither do their parents. It just felt like a slap in the face.

Later some students asked me why I looked so mad and I told them this is not the way a graduation ceremony should be. Their reply was, "This is Central!" For some reason they are proud of being rednecks. They have practically made camouflage the new school color. My brothers and I graduated from a high school in a neighboring city but it was NOTHING like this-- it was serious and respectful, and I only remember seeing one beachball.

I WISH the worst thing that happened was the kids tried to put on sunglasses. But at my school and apparently other schools too there are much worse things that happen at graduation, and I think this is what they were trying to avoid.

After my experience, I understand where that administration is coming from and I totally agree with having rules about what is and is not ok during a graduation ceremony. There is time to celebrate in a fun way later, but the graduation ceremony is a time to honor the graduates and show that achieving this level of education is an accomplishment to be valued.

However, I don't feel it was the student's fault that her family cheered-- she should not be the one to face the consequences. Removing the loud audience members would have been more appropriate.
 
Last edited:
WOW. I am so sorry the graduation was horrible. It seems that graduations have become more extreme since I have graduated and if this is the way they are I understand even more why the subject school took such drastic measures. You give a little bit of room for celebration and chaos breaks out.
I am going to one here in an hour - I hope it goes well.
 
Good luck, K-ma!!
Our class tryed doing some prank at graduation (can't remember what it was), but the attept was blocked. The faculty only really had to worry about stink bombs and silly string....that I recall.
 
All we did was put a marble into the hand of our principal for graduation. He had a lovely pile of marbles on the floor after we regurgitated from high school.

In this case, punishing the student for the misdeeds of family and friends is indeed very harsh. Apparently the school district doesn't understand where to put the blame.
 
The graduation we went to was so nice. The kids were great and the crowd appropriately congratuatled but I did see one faculty member with a beach ball.....
 
As far as I can remember, I have never had to use my High School Diploma for anything official. Colleges use your transcripts, I have never been asked to show my diploma as proof that I graduated for anything- work/school/other. It cannot be used for proof of ID. Even when I had to prove who I am to get a new social security card (I waited too long after getting married to keep it simple) they wanted my transcripts, not the diploma. The transcripts showed DOB.

It is only a fancy paper keepsake that eventually will get stuck in a box along with your prom program and a bunch of other things having been replaced by more important stuff.

OK- the kids should not be punished for what their families did, but it will not, in the end change who they are. That is high school graduates.

pinkflutterbys said,
When parents saw us taking the beachballs and silly string, they booed us and yelled that the kids were just having fun. It was terrible.... ...I spend all day every day making sure every student in my class has the opportunity to walk across that stage and they don't even care enough to give their own accomplishment the respect it deserves, and neither do their parents.

These are the same parents that are in denial that their kids could do anything wrong or write off the wrongdoings as "they are only kids having fun". They have not taught respect, humility or even common courtesy in their homes.
My husband works in a high school and has told me some horror stories.
I am sure there were parents in attendence that were just as appalled as you.
 
All we did was put a marble into the hand of our principal for graduation.

We did this too! But there were only 42 of us. When the Headmaster handed me my diploma, I shook his hand, giving him the marble, and told him that I wasnt wearing any underwear. FUNNY!
 
We did this too! But there were only 42 of us. When the Headmaster handed me my diploma, I shook his hand, giving him the marble, and told him that I wasnt wearing any underwear. FUNNY!


would have been funnier if you had shown him
 
Back
Top