You can probably do more with a computer burner than with a set-top recorder. A computer recorder allows you to use it for data backup, and do more to transfer your old videotapes. That's still a project I'm going to work on eventually. If you buy a capture card and use a VCR and plug it in, you can capture the video into your computer and once it's digitalized, you'll have more options in terms of making menus etc. on your new DVDs. Either way, when you buy a computer, DVD burners come in most of them these days or they're available for not much at all, so if you wanted to get both, it's not going to be that expensive.