Really enjoyed this movie. Songs were great and clever dialog. Actors were very good, even Renee Zellweger, who isn't my favorite actress, but she did a good job with this part.
I think it's horrendous. Awful music and insipid lyrics, middling performances, soulless direction, flat photography, and sets that didn't upgrade from their stage origins --and so look 'unfinished/without detail' rather than stylized. It's a weak story, told unmemorably. Other than that, it's The Best Picture of the Year.
4